Carlo's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Step into Carlo's Pizza on Seneca Ave, Ridgewood, where classic Italian-American flavors meet fast, friendly service. Our menu offers a wide variety of hearty pizza slices, including our famous cheese pizza and crispy Sicilian slice, perfect for a quick lunch or dinner. Craving something beyond pizza? Try our flavorful chicken parm or a fresh garlic knots basket. We serve up hot, delicious food with genuine pride, whether you're dining in, grabbing takeout, or enjoying our speedy delivery. We add a local touch, supporting Ridgewood families with every slice. Our prices stay friendly — most dishes hover between $1 and $10 — making Carlo’s a neighborhood staple for locals and visitors alike. Join us for lunch, dinner, or a quick snack and see why we get rave reviews from the community.

Carlo's Pizza Menu image 1
Carlo's Pizza Menu image 2
Carlo's Pizza Menu image 3
Carlo's Pizza Menu image 4
Carlo's Pizza Menu image 5
Carlo's Pizza Menu image 6
Carlo's Pizza Menu image 7
Carlo's Pizza Menu image 8
Carlo's Pizza Menu image 9
Specialties
Soups
Salads
Wings
Pasta Specialties
Spaghetti Pasta Specialties
Fettuccini Pasta Specialties
Penne Pasta Specialties
Ziti Pasta Specialties
Pasta Specialties Baked Dishes
Chicken Specialties
Tilapia and Seafood Specialties
Lasagna Combination Plates
Baked Ziti Combination Plates
Manicotti Combination Plates
Stuffed Shells Combination Plates
Ravioli Combination Plates
Calzones and Rolls
Burgers
Pizza
Hot Heros
Side Orders
Desserts
Beverages
Carlo's Pizza

Interior, Food, and Ambiance at Carlo's Pizza

Carlo’s Pizza offers a casual, cozy setting perfect for locals, groups, and solo diners. Its unpretentious vibe creates a welcoming atmosphere where everyone feels at home. The space is wheelchair accessible, with seating and parking designed for comfort. During lunch or dinner, you’ll find a lively, friendly crowd sharing slices and enjoying quick bites. The cooks focus on quality, making sure each pizza and entrée hits the right spot. Our friendly staff greets you with a smile, ready to serve up your favorites fast.

Whether you're popping in for a slice or settling in for a full meal, Carlo’s combines neighborhood charm with excellent food and swift service, making it a go-to spot for Ridgewood.

Carlo's Pizza

About Carlo's Pizza Food and Specialties

Carlo’s Pizza shines brightest with its authentic, Italian-American comfort food. Our signature cheese pizza draws consistent praise, cooked to perfection with just enough oil for that classic New York taste. Pair it with garlic knots, packed with flavor and served fresh out of the oven, or indulge in our chicken parm, complemented by fresh marinara sauce and a squeeze of lemon for extra zing. We also serve popular regional favorites like pepperoni rolls and garlic bread. Our menu features a variety of small plates and quick bites, perfect for solo diners or groups celebrating in the neighborhood.

We prioritize quality, using fresh ingredients for dishes like fried calamari and spinach rolls, ensuring each bite delivers satisfaction. Whether you’re craving a quick snack or a full Italian feast, Carlo’s brings the taste of Italy straight to Ridgewood.

Carlo's Pizza

At Carlo’s Pizza, our commitment extends beyond just serving delicious food. We aim to be a vital part of Ridgewood’s neighborhood fabric, offering authentic Italian-American flavors at honest prices—$1 to $10 usually—catering to all locals. Our specialties include crispy garlic knots, flavorful pepperoni rolls, and the classic cheese pizza with a perfect balance of oil and crispiness. We focus on quick service, especially during peak dinner hours on Fridays and Saturdays, to keep your experience smooth.

Our vision is to build a community hub where everyone feels welcomed—kids, seniors, and even dogs outside. We’re dedicated to maintaining high standards and preserving the traditions that make our pizza special. Every slice we serve carries the love of genuine Italian recipes, served with a side of neighborhood warmth.