Carlo's Pizza

Authentic neighborhood Italian-American restaurant in Ridgewood, NY, offering delicious pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and more. Enjoy quick service, dine-in, delivery, and takeout in a cozy, casual setting. Perfect for lunch, dinner, or catering.

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Carlo's Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Carlo's Pizza
Carlo's Pizza
Carlo's Pizza
Carlo's Pizza

Step into Carlo's Pizza, a cozy, family-run Italian-American spot at 5-75 Seneca Ave, Ridgewood, NY 11385. Since opening, we've served fresh, hot pizza with a classic New York taste that keeps locals coming back. Our unpretentious atmosphere makes every meal feel like a visit to a friend's home. Whether you're stopping in for our thin-crust cheese slices, hearty pasta dishes, or quick bites like garlic knots, every dish is crafted with care and authenticity. We pride ourselves on fast service, whether you’re dining in, grabbing takeout, or getting your favorite meal delivered across Ridgewood.

Our community appreciates our warm vibe, affordable prices, and a menu that hits all the right notes for lunch, dinner, or a casual solo outing. Drop by, meet your neighbors, and enjoy authentic Italian-American flavors that speak for themselves.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

5-75 Seneca Ave, Ridgewood, NY 11385, United States

Phone

+1 718-386-8526

About

The Culinary Story

Carlo's Pizza
Carlo's Pizza
Carlo's Pizza
Carlo's Pizza

Carlo’s Pizza has quietly become a cornerstone of Ridgewood’s vibrant food scene since its founding. Located just a short drive from nearby Glendale, our spot exudes a casual, cozy vibe ideal for relaxing solo dining or group gatherings. Our menu centers around reliable, delicious Italian-American staples—pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and more—prepared with fresh ingredients and a dash of neighborhood charm. We source our marinara sauce and cheeses locally when possible, ensuring every dish bursts with flavor. Our community feels like family here—regulars talk about visiting for the best Sicilian slice, garlic knots, and chicken parm in town.

We believe food builds bonds, so we focus on quick, flavorful service and a welcoming atmosphere that invites everyone to linger a little longer. Our goal? To be your neighborhood hub for satisfying comfort food and shared moments over a hot plate.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM–10 PM
  • Monday11 AM–11 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM–11 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM–11 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–11 PM
  • Friday11 AM–12 AM
  • Saturday11 AM–11 PM

At Carlo's Pizza, we combine a simple, welcoming environment with high-quality food and quick service. Our menu offers an array of Italian favorites, from thin-crust cheese pizza to hearty pasta and flavorful garlic knots. We accept reservations for those busy nights and provide wheelchair-accessible seating and parking, ensuring everyone feels comfortable. Our focus remains on delivering consistent, great-tasting food that honors traditional recipes while adapting to modern tastes. With swift service during peak hours—especially our busiest Friday evenings—we keep your meal moving without sacrificing flavor.

Plus, our meals cater to all ages and dietary needs, from kids’ high chairs to dog-friendly outdoor seating for your furry friends. Enjoy your lunch or dinner with convenience, community, and a slice of New York authenticity.

Carlo's Pizza

Our exterior reflects the heart of Ridgewood—inviting, familiar, and vibrant. Bright signage welcomes locals and passersby, while outdoor seating offers a relaxed spot to enjoy your pizza on warmer days. The outdoor area is dog-friendly, allowing your furry friends to join. Inside, the vibe is casual and cozy, with a strong New York charm that resonates through its simple decor and friendly staff. We love the community feel here—families, students, and neighbors sharing good food in a laid-back setting. The outdoor seating is perfect for spontaneous gatherings or quick bites before heading back to your busy day. Carlo's Pizza embodies the spirit of neighborhood eateries, where every visit feels like a quick chat with an old friend.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

best damn Cesar salad!!! even the Cesar slice goes hard, the Alfredo pasta with chicken was also delish, add a fresh squeeze of lemon to both, now youre talkin my language! deff come try this spot, food doesnt disappoint 🫡

x
xXmala b.

The pizza was thin, it had a good New York, taste, enough oil, cooked to the right temperature. I’m coming back again for sure. Small place they did not have many things on the counter to pick from, but the plain slices I got were very good.

M
M D.

Best pizza in the neighborhood! (And it’s not really close) Their zeppole’s are great too.

S
Simon G.

The go-to spot in Ridgewood. The guys here are great, cooks make amazing food, pizza is always on point. I drive from Glendale, easily 10-15 mins away, just to get my pizza from Carlo’s. Highly recommend their food dishes as well, we’ve used them to cater multiple parties as well.

J
Jamie W.

They came with the food fast! Best one in town

A
Anais G.

The best pizza in BK!!! Hands down. Pizza taste amazing, staff is super polite. The baked ziti is fenomenal 🤤 the owners are fantastic people and been in the neighborhood for decades!

W
William A.